By Nila Do Simon
Photography by Ryan Stone
Israel Gutierrez has a sweet jump shot. There’s an ease to the trajectory. His right hand, which has the letter “I” tattooed in Old English font on the underside of his wrist, puts a slight underspin onto the shot. His form is near-perfect while shooting hoops at the outdoor courts on Fort Lauderdale beach. But if Gutierrez is known for anything, it’s not his basketball game; it’s his reporting about basketball.
The nationally recognized sports reporter has written for the Miami Herald and currently covers the NBA for ESPN and espn.com. He is a regular contributor to the programs “The Sports Reporters,” “Around the Horn” and “The Jump,” all of which feature some of the nation’s most popular sports journalists. An occasional sideline reporter, 39-year-old Gutierrez has evolved into a multimedia sports figure, completing the trifecta of media by also co-hosting the weeknight radio show “Jorge and Izzy” with Jorge Sedano on ESPN Radio.
Raised in Miami by Dominican parents, Gutierrez grew up in the heyday of Dan Marino and Don Shula, and the rise of the Miami Heat and Marlins, perfect breeding grounds to develop a love of sports.
“I would read these articles by Dan Le Batard and Dave Hyde, and I thought they were phenomenal,” Gutierrez says. “When I read them, I started experiencing all these emotions. As I got older, I realized they were among the best of the best sports writers.”
After getting a taste of journalism as editor of his high school yearbook, Gutierrez went on to study at the University of Florida, where classmate Jesse Eisenberg (now the fantasy sports editor at Yahoo) introduced Gutierrez to sports writing at the student-run newspaper, The Independent Florida Alligator. The rest, as they say, is history. He interned at the Palm Beach Post, who eventually hired Gutierrez when he graduated.
He covered a few local sports teams for less than a year before earning an opportunity few rookie writers are bestowed: After writer Ethan Skolnick left to work at the Herald, Gutierrez was asked to take over Skolnick’s beat covering the Florida Marlins for the Post. Soon after, he was asked to cover the Heat.
“After graduating college, I was asked where I saw myself in 15 years, and I said I’d be happy being the NBA beat writer for a major metro newspaper,” Gutierrez says. “I had no idea that it would happen within 10 months.”
Like the athletes he covers, Gutierrez’s work is precise, focused and full of emotion. When he was 22, he wrote a memorable piece about Heat power forward Alonzo Mourning that discussed almost everything except the basketball star’s on-court feats. Instead, it focused on his health battles, which included a life-threatening kidney disease that curtailed the former Defensive Player of the Year’s playing career for two seasons. Though Mourning’s health issues were well-documented through various news sources, Gutierrez says he did something that separated him from other writers: He sought an interview with Mourning’s foster mother, Fannie Threet.
“For some reason, no one thought to call her to get her thoughts,” Gutierrez says. “And she told me his condition was bad. Very bad. And that he needed a transplant soon.”
The story made the front page of the Post, and it created a bond between Mourning and Gutierrez that Gutierrez says helped launch his career. “Zo and I developed a trust that allowed me to have the best stuff on him,” Gutierrez says. “I felt proud that it was a story I took and developed at such a young age.”
Gutierrez would go on to write more nationally recognized NBA pieces, including an in-depth interview with the Heat’s Dwyane Wade, known as the face of the franchise for more than a decade, that openly discussed the star’s willingness to step aside to allow the newly added LeBron James to take control of the team’s reins. The story was so big in the sports world that parts of the interview even ran throughout the day on ESPN’s ticker.
When asked how he is able to connect with sports stars to eke out such intimate quotes, Gutierrez is a bit stumped. After a moment of reflection, he says, “I feel like I get people really well. I can connect with people, and I can translate what they are thinking and saying. At the end of the day, I’m not sure Dwyane would have gotten that comfortable with someone else.”
Gutierrez’s ability to connect with others, along with his sports acumen, has served him well as a contributor at ESPN. He remembers his first time on “The Sports Reporters,” a program where four rotating journalists talk about the week’s sports news in a roundtable discussion, as being filled with nerves and, well, a stench.
“The show is filmed on Sunday mornings in Times Square at ESPN Zone, which is basically a bar that probably hosted a pretty late night the night before, so there was this smell to it,” says Gutierrez of his debut appearance on the program in September 2008. “I remember stepping onto the set, where the makeup artist had a dim spotlight to work with, and there was a small table with a few bagels and some coffee. Not glamorous at all.”
But what was glamorous was Gutierrez’s performance that day. To use a sports term, he hit it out of the park. Mike Lupica, a prominent sports writer and regular guest of “The Sports Reporters,” said he was impressed with Gutierrez’s research and preparation.
Gutierrez also makes regular appearances on “Around the Horn,” a fast-paced talk show where journalists vie for host Tony Reali’s approval on their opinions of sports news. “The first time I did the show, I remember the producers wanting to tape with a cliche backdrop of the ocean, so they picked a spot in Sunny Isles,” Gutierrez says. “But all I remember was what was in the background: a Benihana! So in addition to that classic concept of a beachy Miami backdrop, there is a cheesy Japanese building that was behind me the whole time.”
“It’s a rare thing for someone in this business to be themselves,” says Reali of Gutierrez. “Being themselves on television is a scary thing for everybody, but Israel has always been authentic.”
But, in fact, Gutierrez wasn’t quite himself, something only close friends and family members knew. In an industry where journalists are innately conditioned to never become part of the story, Gutierrez made national news this past September by airing out a bit of his personal history. The renowned writer, who is enveloped in the heavily machismo world of sports, is gay. After coming out to his family in 2009, Gutierrez felt the time was ripe to declare it to the world. Speaking about it today at a coffee shop a few miles from his Wilton Manors home, he is still emotional from his public announcement.
“I went through how I would tell this a million times,” he says. “I thought about doing it short and sweet on TV, or saying it on the radio. I talked to Le Batard at least three or four times about how I should do it.”
Instead, Gutierrez settled on the medium with which he began his career: writing. He created a WordPress site for the sole purpose of housing his coming out statement. The site has only one post, his 1,806-word piece announcing himself as a proud homosexual man who was getting married in a few short weeks to the love of his life, David Kitchen. In the post, which Gutierrez titled, “Thanks for Reading,” he wrote how he initially denied his sexual orientation, how sometimes he wished he wasn’t gay.
But in the end, all the prayers “worked, because I eventually saw my true self, and I’ve never been happier,” he wrote.
During the days leading up to Gutierrez coming out publicly, “There was a mix of a lot of silent support,” Kitchen says. “I was just there, in the present, and there was a lot of spontaneous tears.”
Immediately after he posted the piece, the reaction was met with an outpouring of support. FIFA World Cup Champion Abby Wambach, a fellow Gator and an openly gay athlete, told Gutierrez that he “saved lives.” Rick Welts, president of the Golden State Warriors and one of the few openly gay executives in professional sports, congratulated Gutierrez for his brave act.
For all the internal back-and-forth that Gutierrez did about whether or not to write the post, he says today that, “I have comfort in knowing that it was done right.”
“In the nine months that he’s come out publicly, he has been somebody to allow his heart to beat outside of his body,” Reali says. Referencing a recent segment of the show called “Face Time”—an uninterrupted 30-second monologue by the winning journalist—Gutierrez spoke about deadbeat fathers. “Something similar happened to his family member, and he was OK speaking about it instead of holding it in.”
Reali isn’t the only one who’s noticed a difference since the coming out note. So has Gutierrez’s husband. “There’s a huge weight off his shoulders,” Kitchen says. “He just seems complete. There was just this one final thing he had to do, and he did it.”
Today, Gutierrez lives with Kitchen and their two dogs, a golden retriever named Huck and a Labrador named Sawyer (yes, after those famous literary friends) in Wilton Manors, a community which Gutierrez says played a huge role in his growth as a homosexual. “I immediately felt a sense of community around me,” he says. “And I needed that.”
It’s a fitting respite for a man who would rather be reporting the news than being a part of it. Here, Gutierrez is himself. And there’s not a day that goes by that he isn’t thankful for it.
Originally appeared in the Summer 2016 issue.